≡
 
 

Long before its adoption as the name of official Russian media Novosti's global cable television outlet, now simply "RT," Russia Today appeared at the head of a forgotten column appearing in the Ottawa Citizen of February 25, 1931—a letter from a former Ottawan, "A. Benenson," now living in the Soviet Union and working as a manager on a kolkhoz near Krasnodar. He bemoans the plight of the Soviet Union beset by belligerent neighbors, calling out Poland in particular, and asks the rhetorical question, where is Latvia now without the Soviet Union?

As a western border region on the Black Sea, lying between Ukraine to the north and Georgia to the south, it would not have been totally unreasonable for Soviet authorities to cultivate a fear of the Polish military among Krasnodar's inhabitants, although we've not been able to find any confirmation of two new factories manufacturing poison gas as quoted from Allgemeine Zeitung — which appears to be anti-Polish German propaganda. It is not without irony that we observe that it was only another decade before Poland was once again partitioned between the great powers to its east and west; no amount of arms production could have saved Poland in a war on two fronts.

Latvia, it seems, was already a target long before Russia initiated its ritualistic floggings in defense of the Soviet legacy following the eventual collapse of the USSR. Unfortunately, Benenson's account ignores the origin of Latvia's turn to agriculture by necessity, abandoning its pre-war industrial base. That was the evacuation, sabotage, and war-time destruction of all of Latvia's industrial capacity by both tsarist Russia and then the Bolsheviks as they retreated for the last time during Latvia's Brīvības Cīņas, its war of independence.

When we first published Benenson's letter, we speculated he had answered the idealistic call of the early years of the Soviet Union, a time which garnered an air of excitement and romance for the great social experiment—recall the American journalist Jack Reed and those who went to participate. We had no doubts of Benenson's positive aspirations for the future. Given Бененсон is a common Jewish Russian surname, he may have returned to the land of his heritage and familial roots with his expressed interest in the possibility of an autonomous Jewish republic within the Soviet Union per his April 7, 1928 (still in Ottawa) letter to the editor.

We eventually uncovered the facts were far simpler. Abe Benenson wound up in Canada during WWI and eventually returned home.

From this letter to the editor, responding to the sobering wartime news in Diary of Our Own Pepys further below, Benenson was a man of principle and idealism. Nor can we judge him poorly for simply returning home.

R. F. FLEMING, Letter to the Editor

Abe Benenson

Editor, Citizen: I was glad to learn through (Our Own) Pepy's Diary of the welfare of A. Benenson, a Russian youth who lived in Ottawa in the period of the last war. While in a very humble position in life here, he was an earnest student of our language and of our democracy, taking some part in the discussions in the old Arts & Letters Club which held meetings in the Carnegie Library. On one occasion he was the cause of a little sensation which reached the headlines of the newspapers next day. Dr. Wilfred Campbell gave us a patriotic address at this time entitled "The Duty of the Hour." In the discussion which followed, Benenson, without any intention of offence or disloyalty, said — "Patriotism does not consist of jingo shouting and singing 'God Save the King': we have saved too many kings already." Under my chairmanship I had the speaker withdraw the remark though he meant it merely from an historical standpoint. Dr. Campbell however was not satisfied, called us "a nest of traitors" and had us all get up to prove our loyalty by singing "God Save the King" (except two who would not be coerced), the only time the national anthem was sung at the Library.

But Benenson spoke rightly on that occasion. The day of unworthy kings and dictators should be over for all time.

The few who knew A. Benenson here wish him and his family everything good in his native land.—R. F. FLEMING, Ottawa, Oct. 7, 1945.

The coming war, instigated by Hitler's and Stalin's partnership, did not spare Abe Benenson's family. We found this stoic—and wrenching—account fourteen years later in The Ottawa Evening Citizen of October 6, 1945:

Diary of Our Own Pepys1

Monday, October 1

A FOUL MORNING and so to the office and a letter there from Moscow, from A. Benenson, that I knew well 25 years ago in Ottawa, who writes to me a sad story bravely and uncomplainingly, of how he escaped the Germans at Krasnodar but had to leave his family behind, and how his sister lived through the siege of Leningrad, and how at last his family were united in Moscow, only to hear of the death of Willy:

"Our sorrow came late in March this year. We were, in a way, like ancient Job of old. We went through a lot, but our lives were spared. Then we lost our oldest boy, Willy, at the front. He was only 19, and had been drafted into the army at 16, but a very brave chap. Had he lived he would probably have been named a Hero of the Soviet Union. He was rewarded thrice, was thrice wounded, and had a most spectacular record."

He has lost all his belongings, including extra clothes, and says, "You in Canada have perhaps not felt the times as we have," a masterpiece of understatement, I mused. . . .

E.W.H. [Ernest W. Harrold2]

We honor the suffering and heroism of those whose only act was to face the Nazi onslaught with bravery and unswerving determination. Still, if we take Hitler at his word, Stalin's preemptive ultimata and invasions from Finland in the north to Romania in the south were tipping points in his decision to invade the USSR.3 We cannot dismiss the possibility that Operation Barbarossa was, at least in part, a fruit of Stalin's own sowing.

We return to 1931, when it appeared to some that a besieged and maligned Soviet Union was genuinely the only country truly interested in peace.4 Read it also for Benenson's account of Latvia's struggle to recover after World War I.


1Pepys refers to Samuel Pepys and the diary he kept from 1660 to 1669, including observations and accounts of the Stuart Restoration, the Great Plague of London, the Second Anglo-Dutch War and the Great Fire of London.
2Harrold passed away at the age of 56 only weeks later, on October 22nd. His record of his time at the Ottawa Citizen was published in 1947, as The Diary of Our Own Pepys: Record of Canadian Life.
3The German press release of June 22, 1941, the day Operation Barbarossa was launched, commenced as follows (our emphasis): "This morning the Führer, through Reich Minister Dr. Goebbels, issued a proclamation to the German people in which he explains that after months-long silence he can finally speak openly to the German people about the dangerous machinations of the Jewish-Bolshevik rulers in Soviet Russia. After the German-Russian Friendship Treaty in the Autumn of 1939, he hoped for an easing of tensions with Russia. This hope, however, was crushed by Soviet Russia's extortionist demands against both Finland and the Baltic states as well as against Romania." The USSR invaded Finland on November 30, 1939 after it refused to sign a Pact of Mutual Assistance; and invaded the Baltics—despite their having capitulated and signed such Pacts under direct threat of invasion—on June 14, 1940 while the world was focused on the fall of Paris to the Germans that same day. Lastly, the Soviets issued an ultimatum to Romania and occupied Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina on June 28, 1940 and in the days following. Regardless of the partition of Poland at the start of the war, indications are that the Germans may well have viewed the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact's "spheres of influence" in the buffer states lying between them exactly as stated and not as direct invasion and occupation, other than the partition of Poland which commenced WWII.
4viz., for example, the similarity to subsequent Soviet allegations at The Treaties of Non-Aggression and Neutrality Between the U.S.S.R. and the Baltic States.
"Russia Today" appeared in The Ottawa Citizen edition of February 25, 1931. This is one of a number of such letters published in the The Ottawa Citizen with Benenson's bylines from across the Soviet Union. The dates of his letters to the editor indicate the Benenson family emigrated to the U.S.S.R. some time after 1928.
1928The Four New Baltic States1929Latvian Butter19311935Freedom Monument1936Is War Inevitable?
© 1998 – 2026, S.A. & P.J.Vecrumba | contact [at] latvians.com   Latvians.com on Facebook Peters on Bluesky Peters on Twitter Silvija on Bluesky Terms of Use Privacy Policy Facebook ToS Web presence by Dynamic Resources